Its best explained by this thread: https://mstdn.jp/@GrapheneOS@grapheneos.social/117645039420648634
TL:DR is that Google’s business side is threatening to revoke android licenses from phones that support GOS and is likely planning to lock the bootloaders on Pixel phones going forward. Important to note is that in GOS own words, the actual Google Android team is seemingly not down with it and has helped GOS work on things like Vanadium. As it stands it seems like Graphene is trying to take legal action against Google.
Edit: apparently they’re also on track to start making new Android feature updates exclusive to the Pixel line of phones. We’re really in for a major shakeup in the phone market it seems.
I have been saying this day would come, and I intend to switch to Nura which is based on Alpine Linux instead of being AOSP based.
I have been thinking Google was going to attack AOSP systems for a very long time, and it’s coming true.
New Android features at this point are pretty much just “Gemini can now wipe your ass for you”
so i guess its time for dual wielding?
Left hand Google BS phone. Right hand personal phone, maybe a Linux phone?
Anything but Apple. I used to be in their system, and i dont want to sell my kidneys just to get something fixed.
Something to think about: If GrapheneOS grows in usage their clientele are targets that Google wants. The framing by some users of Google harassing a tiny minority of consumers fails to understand that Google is a surveillance company. If all the high-value targets migrate entirely of Google’s platforms their leverage to secure governmental contracts weakens significantly.
I also think it’s the typical managerial class being disconnected entirely from the realities on the ground and within the organization’s working-class. Many of Google’s employees are against the position and direction the company’s moving towards. Google has a powerful monopoly and everything should be done to weaken it. Users should donate to GrapheneOS just in solidarity–take them to court and set precedent; what Google is doing should be illegal.
Yeah anyone under the illusion that google was ever a good company because of the free apps & services is really kidding themselves…
The linuxOS for phones is going to be a very welcome addition to the market.
yes many google haters around, so be it! many apple haters etc. We can’t all get along of course
If they kill graphene then I guess I’ll go back to iPhones. Fuck Google.
Gross. That walled garden is the same exact evil with less flexibility.
Meh. The way I see it, I can choose to use their walled garden services, or I can choose to use other services like I am now on GrapheneOS. I played with an iPhone recently after being on GrapheneOS for a number of years and the few things I want/need like a keepassXC client (which worked way better on iOS btw) and a basic web browser with adblock are there anyways.
Regarding less flexibility… I really don’t care. I don’t want to customize anything, I just want stuff to work.
Problem is Apple gadgets drill a blackhole in one’s pockets. :(
I was about to reply that iPhones aren’t THAT much more money. Then I went and checked the prices. Yuck.
Motorola is releasing its first Graphene phone in 2027. While it’ll be expensive, it probably shouldn’t take long for things to get cheaper—given that it’s Motorola.
Graphene seems pretty adamant that the security will be close to if not as good as it is on a pixel but I want to wait and see more before I get on board with that.
Ideally we should be pushing for Linux phones but I don’t see that becoming a thing for another 5+ years before Normie’s even really consider it. Things are different now though who knows, things are moving faster and more unpredictably.
Just in the past 5-6 years I feel like I’ve seen Linux move from this niche thing to something I could hand off to anyone and they would do okay-ish. So many small qols, and hardware issues just fixed. You used to just not be able to use 60% of GPUs, or had to use weird community drivers. I can’t express how impressive it is I don’t have to check proton db anymore. When I first got my steam deck it barely played anything besides 2d platformers on proton, and native Linux games. And before that you had to manually find a list of all the winefix things you had to do, and make your own wine prefix and none of it made sense and most of the time it didn’t work for some reason unknown to you. Things aren’t perfect still but its to the point shit just works.
Maybe I’m too hopeful I just don’t feel too confident piggy backing off google when we are essentially splitting off from their official version now. If I understood correctly graphene will have to reverse engineer updates which doesn’t sound promising. My only other hope is that we can force google to play nicely legally, they are easily a monopoly. I believe Tim Sweeny’s law suit against google was about that, sadly google seems to be responding by doubling down, and panicking that people don’t want to use the google playstore. Which is filled with malware, scams and endless slop.
There is a super massive Android ecosystem out there, and contrary to the computer situation, AOSP is a thing. It would take dramatically less efforts to fork AOSP than to bring the GNU/Linux phones up to speed.
Less effort on the OS, less effort from phone makes, less to no effort from the apps dev.
I don’t expect GOS to take on that alone, but there is a potential common interest from states seeking sovereinty, phone makers, other alternative Android distros.
I would bet more on that.
I am not doubting GOS claims, but what evidence is there about Google threatening to revoke licences to OEMs based on collaboration with GOS?
Do you remember when Google released android, not to profit, but as a strategic play against other market movers.
Well now Google has closed that up and they’ve opened up a huge opportunity for others, who is going to be the next Android?
and they didn’t even make it themselves. they bought out android.
That’s like saying that Microsoft didn’t make (pre-NT) Windows because Bill Gates bought QDOS.
android was way closer to how they ended up releasing it than dos was similar to windows 9x.
I don’t see why Google would care that much. The power of the default means 99.9% of phones are going to run whatever they came preinstalled with. So let that 0.01% exist so if regulators start making noises they can claim they’re open. Because they are. But attempting to shit on that % or being overtly hostile exposes them legally far more than just leaving things the way they are.
I don’t think Google cares about hobbyists and enthusiasts installing alternate operating systems.
Google cares very much about OEMs selling phones with non-GMS Android. SafetyNet first appeared not long after the Amazon Fire Phone, a phone preloaded with an Android fork and Amazon’ services and app store instead of Google’s. That failed on its own merits, but someone could have done it better.
Long time ago, Microsoft fell down on a PC maker proposing a dual-boot Windows/BeOS: either they were dropping Be, or they would no longer get OEM preferred price on Windows (a big difference with consumers direct selling price).
Windows was already at those 99.9% share.
Why? Because once you prove the alternative is viable, more hardware vendors will propose the alternative, and before you know, you have a real competition to deal with, and you fight for market share.
I don’t think they need to “care”, but keeping the door open a little, even to forks like Amazon / Baidu or whoever means they have some legal protection from claims the platform is a monopoly.
It’s in their interest for forks to exist and have a tiny market share of enthusiasts who were never going to be very profitable for Google anyway, but ensure there are enough usability issues those forks never take off with mainstream users.
I feel like it’s not a market share thing. If I had to take a guess, it’s pressure from governments. Governments really don’t like people having phones without Spyware on them. Especially “free” countries.
I mean, Google has also been trying to twist arms in education recently as well, I think their assumption now is “We are too big to regulate” and just dgaf if what they’re doing is illegal.
It sets a precedent that (to them) threatens that 99.9% share dropping.
Previously google forced manufacturers’ obedience and kept them from shipping devices with better OSes or “forks” by using their anti fragmentation licensing requirements. If Sony for eg wanted to sell one phone with a fork preloaded with lineageOS or something, they’d lose their android certification for all of their phones including those that didn’t ship with LOS (keeping them from shipping devices with google play store, gapps etc).
The European Commission ruled this anti-competitive in 2018 and now Motorola, a major manufacturer, is ‘threatening’ to sell a high end flagship with a much more secure and privacy respecting OS that makes google’s surveillance-malware infested flagship look like the steaming turd it is. So of course they’re going to throw threats and litigate to protect their profits.
Because if there’s literally no alternative they can go rampant abusing customers. At the moment they have to keep some check on their abuse.
Time for Linux based handhelds with WiFi, and a dumb phone with a hotspot.
Go straight for a Linux phone - while arguably less convenient in some ways than Android, they do work for all the calls, messaging, browsing.
Ironically, Linux is what keeps my way EOL Pixel 3 running and freshly updated, without Google’s hands in it anymore.
Ooh I’ve got an EoL pixel . What are you using?
Nura KDE, they have a very stable build for Google Pixel 3a (and 3a XL)
Not sure about how it currently is with other Pixels.
Ahh thanks for the recommendation. Unfortunately looks like pixel 3 is the only supported device. I shall continue meandering for a pixel 5
Ironically I think that AI will kill off the dominance of apps. With an easier entry into coding, people can duplicate apps into websites if they want. And the shine of everything being an app is wearing off, as tech gurus more their attention away and onto AI. So small handhelds with wifi might become prevalent.
Not sure I want to embrace that era of slop apps. I’m raging enough against half-baked corporate websites already.
And let’s be frank: are we going to use vibe-coded slop apps probably filled with security flaws if not introcucing backdoors on purpose because we can’t use GOS anymore?
I hope you’re right.
Yes I’ve already made several paid/ad supported apps into a Web app for myself using AI. You can even make it “installable” and near indistinguishable from a normal app if you make it into a PWA.
Bonus you get to fine tune all of those “I wish it had this” or “I wish it didn’t do that” you have to usually put up with using other people’s apps.
After they make Linux typesafe first.
What?
Linux kernel is largely not type-safe or memory-safe because over 99% of it is written in C. This opens it up to significantly more attack.
There have been hopes that someone with a lot of money (e.g. Google or Apple) would fork it and rewrite it in Rust or another type-safe language.
Do you have publications in programming language theory?
What?
So how hard would it be to get most of Linux contributors to revoke Google’s right to redistribute their code in the Android kernel in retaliation?
Very hard if not impossible at this stage, and you’re talking about Linux giving up freedom to own one corp. It would be a blood bath, and you would give big corps an incentive to fork Linux and dry their funding of the common parts.
Much harder than forking Android…
We had the tivoization drama years ago and Linus came down on the idgaf side.
RMS is the man you are looking for.
I feel like this guy must be surrounded by way too many MBAs the way he falls on things sometimes.
Linus has never been a hardliner his whole career.
Except when it’s about nvidia.
Yeah that is true
Yeah I wouldn’t count on Linus himself ever GAF about such things. But he is just one person in a much larger community.
He also started Linux on the premise that everyone should be able to access an operating system for free. Really it was him wanting to have his own operating system and just letting people use it for free if I remember the stories I heard a really long time ago.
Wrong. RMS started gnu for having freedom as in liberty.
Linus was learning about operating systems . Linux was intended for only 385 systems and not as professional as GNU.
Every project Google starts, ends up getting killed eventually.
Android is just one of the longest projects to date. Sure enough, like everything else, if they feel they cannot make enough of a return from it they’ll kill it too. Because it was never about the community. It was about profit.
I’ve been bitching about Google’s Android moves for ages and everyone just dismisses it and says move to eOS or gOS like they aren’t going to take them down eventually.
Linux for phones is coming. My next concern is that Banks, Websites and Phone providers start blocking Linux phones because Google and Apple tell them to.
I’m all for a proper Linux phone
I need a big OEM to pick up
PostmarketOSNura and throw development resources at it to use it mainline like how Valve put time and money into gaming on Linux.All the Chinese OEMs still use a downstream Android fork to retain full compatibility with Google’s stupid ideas. We already have Waydroid and Lepton because Android ultimately runs on Linux anyway, you just need to supply APKs with the Android environment.
You just pointed the issue and solution: Chinese OEM managed to fork Android, and quickly. Per your own admission, you would need a large funding to get Nura ready.
Why not having a large alliance forking Android for good? Cheaper, faster, safer. Low effort to port existing apps. If we trust GOS (and I assume we’re in this thread becau#e we do…), Waydroid is unsafe, and the GNU/Linux model is also less secure.
GNU/Linux is designed assuming you will use a full opensource ecosystem, all apps playing nicely. That’s doable on smartphone, but you’ll have to give up banking, service’s apps, etc.
Android was designed assuming bad actors apps will get on the device. A lot of GOS work is to reinforce the restictions of what apps can see and do.
Yes!
One of the biggest issues of Nura us that we don’t have enough newer phones that support it, and it’s because it takes community a long while to reinvent the wheel.
If vendors could at least stop getting in the way, mobile Linux experience could be complete and thriving tomorrow
I hate Google. This company is mediocre and unfair. Isn’t threatening to shut down Android enough? Are we just their puppets? They collect our data, and now this? Things just keep getting worse. Google wants to screw over everyone who uses Android.
If I could go back, I would’ve bought a phone that came with GrapheneOS instead of using this damn Samsung, Google’s lapdog.
Its not mediocre
Its a company that started out as a great software development company and an ally to the FOSS community, bit then over time, as is inevitable, especially with successful companies, money and greed took over and turned the software company into an evil marketing company that happens to also still do some software but whongivea a crap about that, money money money
Software should not be allowed to be closed source anymore, software should not be allowed to be owned by companies anymore
Hmm… I take issue with “started out as … ally to the FOSS community.”
I remember them hiring many OSS developers. But I always thought it was a “cheaper this way than that way” sort of thing.
Hmm. You know how people often “look to their past” to “understand them today.” Well, I think we should also “look at who they are today, to understand their motives in the past.”
Dunno. I’m super cynical.
It was either that, or buy into Apple’s locked down since day one ecosystem.
At the time, android and Google were heroes. Damn shame the state of affairs now.
Are we their puppets?
No, we’d be so lucky. A puppet is a capital asset and needs to follow the standard devaluation curve. We’re the users. Not even customers or consumers anymore. We’re a part of their product, in their minds we’re not humans or persons anymore. Just the thing that uses the thing and they’re desperately trying to replace us because we push back.
They own us all from. Our hair to our arms and legs, our penises and vaginas for reproduction and even our buttholes to search for diseases. They control what we can say and what they allow us to hear and see and do. I say fuck them. Make this Friday a nice black Friday. Stay home and read a book. Don’t buy anything. Let’s see if we still matter.
So it’s better to give up and get away from big tech. If I had a PC, I’d already be working on making my Android phone’s operating system more secure. I’d have switched to something safer by now something that doesn’t treat me as an object to collect information from.










