I don’t fucking know. Small dicks and short stature everywhere I guess. Insecurities abound, but I can’t tell you where they come from.
Hell, I’ve been described as “not the most feminine straight man I know, but up there” a lot. I’ll also add that a lot of women, in general, feel safer to interact with. Idk why.
I guess for me, I’m sexually attracted to women. And I’ve been told my whole life to be myself. So if I act myself around women, and women are attracted to me, that makes me masculine enough doesn’t it?
Insecurity is the core of whatever you’re seeing, whether it’s real or just pushed by algorithms or outlets you see. People who are secure and healthy are too busy living life, working on goals, helping loved ones to be a loud boisterous whiner about cucking, gender issues, tribalism, etc. People who are insecure but want to convince themselves they’re doing everything right and are on the right tribal team will focus on easy targets to believe or claim those people are to blame for their short fallings or what they perceive is holding society back from their vision of a perfect world.
There are monied interests who want to magnify that perception to keep people busy, to convince them to do horrible things, and make money off them.
European men know their worth. American men need to be sold on the concept because nothing counts in america unless it sells.
Because the US is a nightmare land from which we will never wake.
I can only speak for Germany here but German ooga-booga masculinity destroyed the continent twice over and killed almost 100 million people in 25 years. Those wars killed most of those men and convincing new men that such masculinity is the way is a hard sell. It’s making a comeback these days though now that the old generation isn’t there to remind them of where it leads.
I also suspect that the US deliberately promotes this masculinity because of its Militarism. The ultimate expression of the masculine ideal is some form of soldier. Duty to, honor by, and violence for, the state. My grandfather would have had a thing or two to say about it.
Idk, it seems to me they just enjoyed getting fucked in the ass, first by their Führer, and then by the Allies. that’s not exactly what I’d call masculinity, but everyone has their own opinion.
Your American is showing.
and homophobia.
Inferiority complex, making up for it with toxic masculinity.
Europe has older history. We’ve experienced revolutions, wars, changes of regimes and now tend to believe in a more diplomatic approach. We have an older history of education as well. Nowadays, it seems like we want to rconnect with our human side more.
Recently, I’ve watched a documentary about loneliness in our modern digital society. There were a few examples from Germany, France and the UK of how people try to reconnect without the digital tools. There were episodes from a sensual dancing class and a cuddling club. The cuddling club episode was interesting as some men expressed how good they felt in arms of another man. Nothing intimate, just warmth and reconnection with our senses and feeling less lonely. Maybe our past experiences gradually lead us to evolving into more connected and responsible societies.
I wouldn’t say it’s a want of masculinity that differs, more the form it takes.
The typical American media presented loud, brash, devoid of feelings, braggadocio on steroids kind of “ideal man”, is correctly seen for the toxic masculinity it is and generally viewed as pretty vulgar by many on this side of the pond.
Positive masculinity is more about being dependable, open, driven, accountable & respectful. Our media diet tends to reflect this as well as it being an outcome of people participating in functioning communities
Plus guns. Don’t forget guns.
The American one leaks and reaches the European societies as well. I would say this depends on the country and society we want to compare to the American one.
For example, in most Eastern European countries American medias seemingly had a bigger impact on worldview after freedom was restored. The American culture has become an example to strive for. Many guys have started to be brash, willing to be cool and care only about money. Any sign of vulnerability has become something to attribute to being “gay”, which often led to bullying. However, the situation now is changing a bit as men begin to become more mellow so to speak. It’s becoming a norm to be yourself again. Maybe because quite many guys have experienced living and working in the Western European (not American) societies and became more cultured.
Actually, I’m a sociologist from London UK, and have spent years analyzing this phenomenon. The USA is generally obsessed with bigger, larger, more; e.g. children in school are already trained that the USA is the best country in the entire world, and they are also as individuals stimulated to put themselves in the best light. Seen from the outside, US Americans love the Hollywood sparkle, they love hype, they love bravura, the excitement. In contrast, Europeans love a plate with spaghetti and a nice espresso.
Non-socialist from the US here, and though I think your analysis is not wrong, I think it may not apply to masculinity in specific very much.
I think it is more to do with the militaristic nationalism built into our culture. Which tbf, media does erpetuate, but it’s a lot deeper rooted then “the Hollywood sparkle” you mention.
Again, you arn’t wrong, I just think the military nationallism is more to blame in this situation.
obsessed with bigger, larger

incredible
European here - holy shit have you been reading my mail?
This comment is just hogwash observation.
Post your research.
Is this true? Different European cultures are as different from each other as any of them from America, from what I can tell (being a European, specifically Austrian, man).
My stereotype of a typical Dutch or Danish man is certainly different from that of a typical Italian or Serbian man.
Quite! Eastern Europe masculinity is, I feel, very different to that of Western Europe; I’m not saying one is ‘better’ or ‘worse’ than the other. (I am technically British from a Belgian / Acadian family.)
I’ve had friends from different countries, and I’ve noticed a consistent difference between Europeans and Americans. American guys seem more paternal, protective, and self-sacrificing, and a lot of them genuinely dream of having a big family.
Being protective and self-sacrificing are traits that exist entirely separate from gender. You’re going to look someone in the eye and tell them these aren’t common traits among mothers?
Being paternalistic, however, is definitely a toxic masculine trait. Fortunately, it’s on the way out. For millennials on down, men skew toward egalitarianism instead.
None of those are typical “masculine” traits though…
🙄
deleted by creator
Insecurity.
The US is founded on an idea of freedom to soar or sink to one’s level, even at the expense of security or stability, and hence in America people expect to be personally responsible for ensuring their own security rather than expecting society to have safety nets. Psychologically, survival values kick in then, meaning that projecting dominance becomes important. This has intensified in the past 50 or so years as inequality and precarity increased, to the point where a lot of social interactions (i.e. getting around in an automobile among other drivers) resemble the psychology of the prison yard.
personally responsible for ensuring their own security
2nd Amendment mentions Militia, implying cooperation for defence rather than a every man for themselves… but then again, lots of people dont even read the documents they revere.
in practice in the u.s. ‘militia’ is a small group of random neighbors who are somehow both the biggest gun nuts and the stupidest people ive ever seen speak.
i call the 2nd amendment the ‘dead kid’ tax… because we pay every year in the form of dead children all over the country so a bunch of randos can play rambo in their back yards. or gun whackjobs can pretend that they are safer having a gun in the house despite literally every statistic that is available showing otherwise.
if the country ever actually needed a militia to take over a failed government, the fucking amendments sure as fuck arent going to stop humans from doing so. if history has proven anything its that humans are very fucking good at weapons.
Which also implies the “state” will regulate that militia and that every adult man can be called up to preform militia duties as the state sees fit. None of the fuck wits I encounter at the range or gun stores seem to know this. I am a big gun owner and believe in the 2nd Amendment. The 2nd clearly states that the state will regulate guns and the federal has no power to overstep that. While I may not like what some of the state gun laws any law they have is well within their Constitutional duties.
Toxic masculinity is a symptom of conservatism. Conservatism is a contagious social disease that causes harm to the people around the infected person rather than the infected person themselves. Other symptoms include inability to experience empathy and enjoying the suffering of the vulnerable.
Typically, the infected are unaware they have any disease at all. There is no survivable cure. The most common treatment is to distance from the infected. Completely disowning conservatives is the most effective approach. Do not keep company with them; do not do business with them.
While this disease is spreading unchecked throughout the U.S., other nations are vulnerable as well. The UK is reporting millions of cases as is Australia and Russia. No place is safe or immune from conservatism and its symptoms. Be vigilant. If you become aware that someone in your vicinity is infected, distance from them immediately. Disown them and delete them from all aspects of your life.
Conservatives cause harm to everyone around them and will not spare anyone, regardless of relationship. Safety first. Disown them. Delete them.
Toxic masculinity is a symptom of conservatism.
Agree on that one. It’s stemming out of religion. Conservatism is the political culture that aligns with religion. The core of it is religious values but there is a little more going on right now. The gullible religious cult is being manipulated by algorithms on social media. Somebody has found the ultimate fuel to throw on the fire and it is specifically injecting fear and hate into their lives every minute of the day. This is an age old manipulation tactic to control religious people but it’s become very powerful with the help of social media.
I think the toxic masculinity movement is a huge conservative backlash against the cultural shift to recognize LGBTQ rights. Conservatives feel they are in a cultural war and fear that they and their kids are trying to be turned gay, turned trans, or made vulnerable to getting molested in a bathroom because a trans pedo is lurking in there. If you know a conservative from the US, big chance they have ranted about trans lately. The backlash is to push manly man culture and testosterone doping. Your right to be a man is under attack!
This question contains unproven generalisations, for men on either side of the Atlantic. This will create a long thread and I don’t think we will gain a lot of knowledge from it.













