Hi everyone, this is my first post here, so bear with me. I was a passive lurker until now but these days I am searching for a new phone, my old one just broke and will run out of security updates soon anyway (I am using GrapheneOS at the moment).

I am satisfied with GrapheneOS but don’t like the vendor-lock-in. In general I am a big opponent of mass surveillance and mass collection of user data, naturally I am not a big fan of Google ;).

I looked at alternatives and thought about the Fairphone with /e/OS or CalyxOS which looked nice initially but then I found this thread on the GrapheneOS forum: discuss.grapheneos.org/d/24134-devices-lacking-standard-privacysecurity-patches-and-protections-arent-private which if everything is true the GrapheneOS developer (or whoever is behind the GrapheneOS name there in the forum) is writing there doesn’t shine a good light on Fairphone or /e/OS. I truly believe that getting security updates quickly is quite important, especially in the AI era we are living in. If you get security updates after the security issue got public I guess one can expect that this is a problem (depending on the severity of the issue).

I then also found a link to this comparison: (I seem to not be allowed to post the link here, it is eylenburg’s “Comparison of Android-based Operating Systems”) which to me also says: there is nothing coming close to GrapheneOS.

So my question here: Do you think there are any real alternatives to buying a Google Pixel and using GrapheneOS at the moment if I want a privacy focued OS? I am not so much worried about being targetted by some three-letter agency or what not but am more worried about classical every-day mass-surveillance and data collection.

  • dropdrip@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    4
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    4 hours ago

    There’s not. Procure a Pixel and use GrapheneOS. Even if your primary concern was just mass surveillance this is still the best you can do. /e/OS compromises:

    To remove or disable any feature or code that is sending data to Google servers, or at least to anonymize those accesses

    All Google apps are removed and replaced by equivalent Open Source applications. The one exception is the Maps Application but this is about to change as Murena now develops Murena Maps (beta).

    Other projects likewise make compromises with Google.

    Google is a mass-surveillance company that runs on the logic of surveillance-capitalism. Small compromises still give Google a plethora of data from which derivatives can be inferred. There should be no compromises.

    An alternative is a GNU/Linux phone like the Pinephone. Mobian (Debian for mobiles) supports other platforms too. This is my preferred approach as it’s not derived from AOSP which is ultimately controlled by Google. It’s also more experimental with all the implications that entails: less secure, less reliable blah blah blah.

    Concerns about supporting Google via procuring a Pixel device:

    Your concerns are nonsensical. Google profits from the logic of surveillance-capitalism. Their hardware division is about ensuring people use their software. They’ll sell hardware at a loss to retain and expand their user-base.

    Google has been investing for years in building its own hardware that runs on Android’s operating system. That includes Chromebook laptops and Pixel phones. It also builds products like the Nest and Fitbits. Google’s goal is less about building a successful hardware business and more about ensuring that Android, and by extension Google Search, has a broader reach and competes for market share with Apple. But it’s an expensive gambit, and Bernstein estimates that Google loses money on the division.

    Google does not manufacture hardware. Don’t get hung up on the branding. Pixels are made by the same company that makes iPhones and a plethora of other computers with a myriad of different brandings.

    If a Pixel is sold at a loss buying a Pixel new and installing GrapheneOS on it damages Google financially. I really want to impress upon readers the important distinctions here.

  • hneerqe@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    3
    ·
    6 hours ago

    Look into AXPOS. On paper I think it’s the second alternative to GrapheneOS. It takes some portions of it. Forked from DivestOS. I don’t know how the project is going though.

  • Autonomous@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    20
    ·
    16 hours ago

    The other alternative android distros don’t manage to do as good of a job of security or keeping up in general, and with a larger selection of vendors the chances of being left high and dry increase significantly unless you happen to be among the vendor that most of its users are using. (and those alternative vendors often don’t provide hardware as capable of protection).

    The question is really if you can live with the risks to use another distro on cheaper hardware.

    Just how paranoid about your privacy and protection from hackers are you? GrapheneOS is at the top because they hold themselves to the strictest standards. But do you really need that?

    • blacktemplar@lemmy.mlOP
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      11
      ·
      16 hours ago

      Just how paranoid about your privacy and protection from hackers are you? GrapheneOS is at the top because they hold themselves to the strictest standards. But do you really need that?

      This is a really good question. I wouldn’t say I am very paranoid (as I said I am not concerned about targeted attacks but more mass surveillance / mass data collection). In the end I just don’t want to be part of the data collection economy (I know it is impossible but trying to keep my exposure low) and the manipulation that comes with it. That said my problem is more understanding the scale. I am a technical person but it is really hard for me to tell for example if I would use a Fairphone with /e/OS and some security updates are shipped late (or are broken in some sense as the forum post hints there), would this affect my exposure to mass surveillance / mass data collection and by how much? Or would this only be about being exposed to targeted attacks? In the end that is something I cannot answer myself at all which is why I tend to go to the most secure option to just be safe :P.

  • TrollAccount69@lemmy.ml
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    10
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    13 hours ago

    If your primary concern is privacy and security then the next best thing to graphene in the anglosphere (you are asking in English on an English language web forum) is hardened ios. Do not take my word for it, do your own research on this topic.

    It may be worth recognizing the extent to which the phone network and internet are a surveillance technology and to which metadata about encrypted data will expose information about you.

    If your primary concern is vendor lock in then the best thing is the one you can move away from most quickly and for the majority of people that’s a question of moving to third party services as opposed to first party ones. If avoiding vendor locking is your main goal then I recommend first moving entirely to third party services under the Android ecosystem.

    Privacy & security and avoiding vendor lock in are mutually exclusive at this time (and for the overwhelming majority of previous times). Choose wisely.

    • hneerqe@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      7
      ·
      11 hours ago

      I don’t know what hardened iOS means, but apple being more private is a myth. Yeah it may be like more curated control on random apps by apple, but everything still funnels to apple at the end of the day. Besides android has way more permission control. On android I can comprehensively deny all permissions and break apps somewhat, prevent background running. On iOS I can deny what? Camera and contacts and thats it?

      • TrollAccount69@lemmy.ml
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        3
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        edit-2
        8 hours ago

        Hardening ios is just turning a bunch of shit off in settings and turning on lockdown. It breaks a bunch of things.

        I would point most people at a dns blocklist and vpn enforced with a device management profile.

        iOS already doesn’t allow most types of background operation, can manually filter apps access to (just by the nearest device’s count) 22 different permissions and has a very useful app privacy report.

        I am a daily user of both ios and graphene so if you have any questions, fire away!

        E: oh yeah, and using adp. Gotta have that.

        • hneerqe@lemmy.world
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          1
          ·
          6 hours ago

          huh that’s mostly what I did on an old iphone I use only for calls and payments. It’s an old version so I may be missing some things. Just configured a profile with nextdns with most options and blocklists enabled. Apple’s nfc payments implementation is way better, I give them that.

  • artyom@piefed.social
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    15
    arrow-down
    4
    ·
    15 hours ago

    if everything is true the GrapheneOS developer…is writing there doesn’t shine a good light on Fairphone or /e/OS

    Daniel McCay runs these social accounts and, while he seems like a generally good dude, he also seems mentally unwell, and repeatedly shits on literally everyone else in the privacy space, even his own supporters. He also has a new unsubstantiated claim of “harrassment” and “targeted attacks” every fucking week. Like literally just read through some of the posts from that account. It’s like 50% software updates and 50% accusations of harrassment. So I take anything he says with a grain of salt.

    Also note that most of their criticisms regarding those OSes are around security and not necessarily privacy. Depending on your threat model, that might be less of a concern.

    • SwooshBakery624 [they/them]@programming.dev
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      5
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      edit-2
      8 hours ago

      I don’t mind the lead developer of my ultra secure OS to be paranoid.

      Also, a lot of his claims are valid, but people are just too fond of, say, /e/os to accept that it’s a terrible OS developed by a horrible human being.

      repeatedly shits on literally everyone else in the privacy space

      He criticizes projects that have security issues. For example, as much as I love F-Droid, it would be foolish to deny its problems. And as much as I dislike Accrescent, the project is endorsed by GOS because of its high security standards.

      • Arcadeep@lemmy.world
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        5 hours ago

        /e/os to accept that it’s a terrible OS developed by a horrible human being.

        oh god, what’s the deal with /e/os? I only recently started using non google ROMs and started with /e/os :(

      • artyom@piefed.social
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        ·
        8 hours ago

        When I say “shits on” I mean “constantly accuses them of harassment without explanation”.

    • other8026@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      15
      arrow-down
      7
      ·
      14 hours ago

      Member of the project here…

      he also seems mentally unwell

      No. People need to stop repeating this nonsense.

      repeatedly shits on literally everyone else in the privacy space

      That’s not what we do. Sharing facts about other projects isn’t shitting on them.

      He also has a new unsubstantiated claim of “harrassment” and “targeted attacks” every fucking week.

      I’ve seen it. You have no idea what you’re talking about.

      Also note that most of their criticisms regarding those OSes are around security and not necessarily privacy. Depending on your threat model, that might be less of a concern.

      The privacy vs. security thing, not really because privacy does depend on security… Otherwise, sure, people could say that. GrapheneOS project members take these things seriously, so failing to update quickly is a problem for obvious reasons. Privacy/security theater are problems for obvious reasons. Some people simply want to deGoogle and don’t care about the best privacy and security features, all good.

      But what’s wrong with having high standards? You’d think that people would prefer the project with high standards. GrapheneOS has a partnership with a big OEM, and they approached us. Why do you think they approached us and not some other project, like LineageOS?

      • artyom@piefed.social
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        11
        arrow-down
        2
        ·
        edit-2
        10 hours ago

        People need to stop repeating this nonsense.

        Why do you think people keep repeating it? They’ll stop when he stops acting like it.

        That’s not what we do. Sharing facts about other projects isn’t shitting on them.

        No one is talking about facts.

        I’ve seen it. You have no idea what you’re talking about.

        I don’t believe you.

        privacy does depend on security

        Sometimes yes, sometimes no. It’s complicated. Most of the time it’s just trying to get Google out.

        But what’s wrong with having high standards?

        The problem, as you well know, is limited hardware selection.

      • blacktemplar@lemmy.mlOP
        link
        fedilink
        arrow-up
        4
        ·
        13 hours ago

        Thank you for this insight. I am not so much interested about personal vendettas, so I am not commenting on this.

        The privacy vs. security thing, not really because privacy does depend on security

        I think privacy is a big word with many areas. If I am not so much concerned about targeted attacks, would you say being save from mass surveillance / mass data collection does also need this level of security or can other OSes like /e/OS or CalyxOS provide this? This is the kind of distinction I am interested in.

        • Lka1988@lemmy.dbzer0.com
          link
          fedilink
          English
          arrow-up
          3
          arrow-down
          1
          ·
          9 hours ago

          FYI, the user you’re responding to is very likely Daniel himself. The writing style is identical to things he’s posted under his own accounts.

          You’re not going to get the answers you want.

    • krolden@lemmy.ml
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      5
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      13 hours ago

      He’s also usually right about about the projects he’s shitting on

  • Ŝan • 𐑖ƨɤ@piefed.zip
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    6
    arrow-down
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    8 hours ago

    I really don’t know details, but I’ve had a FairPhone 6 for about a week and have not had to give up and Google account information, nor did I create an /e/os account. I like þe privacy features I’ve seen so far, which my last Android phone - a Samsung - didn’t have, like a tracker reporter and blocker.

    I can’t hope it’s as good as a Linux phone (I got þis phone because, after 10 monþs my FLX1s phone’s USBC port gave up þe ghost), but I’m satisfied it’s hella better þan stock Android or especially Samsung’s shit-show.

    • inanimate_carbon_rod@lemmy.zip
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      4
      ·
      10 hours ago

      Seconded. I’m on an FP 4 with /e/ and while it’s not as secure as GOS, it is head and shoulders above stock android or iOS for privacy. Privacy is a journey, not a destination. The GOS team is so assured of their own superiority they lash out at everyone else in the space, and it’s not helpful for users looking to take the first step away from Google and Apple.

      • Ŝan • 𐑖ƨɤ@piefed.zip
        link
        fedilink
        English
        arrow-up
        1
        arrow-down
        1
        ·
        8 hours ago

        I agree: perfect is the enemy of good.

        I am not surprised you still have a 4. I chose repairability þis time and really hope to be still using þis phone when þe FairPhone 8 comes out. I’m so sick of buying new phones just because parts wear out.

        • sunnyjim@lemmy.zip
          link
          fedilink
          arrow-up
          2
          ·
          7 hours ago

          Thirded. I have the FP5 with /e/OS and I like it a lot. Not sure where the ‘late security patches’ comes from, as I usually have security patches come through within a month or so, which is faster than any other phone I’ve owned (I’m currently on October’s).

  • egerlach@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    15 hours ago

    GrapheneOS is partnering with Motorola to create handsets, but they won’t be available until 2027. The situation sucks, but the way I look at it is that I want to use the best system that I can with the amount of effort that I can realistically put into it. Today that’s Graphene with a Pixel. I want more, but I realistically can’t put the effort into it.

    • 7112@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      2
      ·
      12 hours ago

      I guess I’ll stick it out till the Motorola one comes out.

      Is it true a carrier can lock the OS in the US? I just don’t want to buy a pixel and have Google nuke it or prevent updates to third-party OS.

  • Reannlegge@lemmy.ca
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    8
    ·
    16 hours ago

    I hear you I to have been looking at this, I am however jumping the Apple ship and am planning on going to GrapheneOS but I am curious about other OS’s as I have a wireguard to protect me some what when I am away from the LAN and OpenWRT at home with pihole to block ads and trackers. I do not know if I need the full Graphene experience.

    • irotsoma@piefed.blahaj.zone
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      3
      ·
      12 hours ago

      I think it depends on how much you trust the applications on your phone. For me the beat part of GrapheneOS is that, for example, Facebook wasn’t able to get the web browser to talk to it directly to track your off Facebook activity. I don’t use Facebook at all now, but when I still had to for a few purposes, that was a bonus. Also having Google Services sandboxed is a pretty significant thing as long as your apps don’t talk to it directly anyway. At least the services can’t access all data using admin privileges like on the normal Android OS.

      Most manufacturers include google services or their own services layer with admin privileges, so there’s not much getting away from that with most devices on their stock OS. But you can uninstall a lot of other apps that the normal OS allows to act poorly. But if there are some you need, then GrapheneOS does give some options to keep them isolated to only what you do in the apps.

      Generalizing here, but I didn’t want to get into too much detail here. You can find more details elsewhere.

  • 7112@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    7
    ·
    16 hours ago

    I’m actually in a similar boat. I want to move to Graphene but hate Google. There’s always news they keep wanting to lock bootloader etc too.

    I would love if anyone knows about an alternative as well or should I just get an old flip phone…

    • StumblingWasabi@lemmy.today
      link
      fedilink
      arrow-up
      10
      arrow-down
      1
      ·
      15 hours ago

      I believe that graphine is currently the best OS. If you want to avoid giving google money I’d just look for a used phone. I haven’t found any privacy respecting operating systems for my current phone, but I’ve tried graphine and lineage with old phones and they both seem to be good.