Was the game controversial before the conviction?
Yes. They wanted to change the name of one of Elder Gods Shub-Niggurath to Shub-Gorath. Due to the name being “racist”.
If they take the racism out of Lovecraft, what even is left?
Every single time, the people clutching pearls and demanding others “be better” have the worst skeletons in their closets.
In a fair and just world, Chaosium would take the L and donate the $770K to the victims.
Similarly, I will never ever play binding of Isaac because it was made by an abuserMan I had seen this in discussion at length on Reddit and it may be totally bunk. Sorry if that’s fake news.
Do you have a source for that? Quick search turned up nothing substantial
The only thing I found is the unsubstantiated claim that a past website of his had links to CP.
https://www.pcgamesn.com/the-binding-of-isaac/edmund-mcmillen-statement





