I’m on the pathway for setting up a Proxmox cluster with 3 thin clients, 2 of which are deployed (but not the cluster until I get the third machine running). I’m thinking of installing 4 VMs as follows: a) one for OpenWRT so that I can get rid of my SKY router b) one for Opensense c) one for Frigate d) one for Homeassistant/OpenHabian e) one for everything else (about 8 services with docker) The thin clients are Optiplexes with 16-32 GB RAM. Do you think I am overdoing this? Basically I want to keep my network VMs free from everything else so that I don’t have to reboot these when I have to reboot the VM with all the services.


What specific models are you running? I have a trio of Optiplexes on 7th and 8th gen Intel hardware just for Proxmox. It’s great, I can run pretty much whatever I want.
OPNSense already does everything OpenWRT can do, and more.
Frigate runs in Docker. You don’t need a separate VM for it.
I’ve heard of OpenHabian, but there seems to be a lot of tribalism around it.
A single VM can run much more than 8 services without so much as a sneeze.
That is actually part of the reason Docker exists; individual services can be restarted very quickly. I have 4 VMs dedicated to just Docker services, and rarely have to reboot an entire VM unless I specifically did something to it (maybe 3 or 4 times over the last year).
You won’t notice the downtime.
One is optiplex 7070 and the other is a 5070