So first: if you are the sort of person who is outraged at the idea of Idris Elba playing James Bond because James Bond has to be white, please stop reading. This question is not for you.
The question is:
How should we treat racism in speculative fiction?
Yes, it’s nice to have inclusive casting and to, Rodenberry-style imagine a better future, but it’s probably also bad to ignore a core problem of Western civilization and let it go unexamined.
The only good example of addressing racism comes from a Tenant episode of Dr. Who, where they go back to 17th-centuryish England and Martha Jones, Dr. Who’s black companion, explicitly has to adapt to her assigned lower status as a black woman.
But I also have several bad examples:
-
The multi-ethnic village in the Mandalorian that has existed in harmony with nature for millenia, yet there are a wild variety of phenotypes in a small village of maybe 30 people.
-
All the mixed race FEDRA cities in the Last of Us show. You know those mother fuckers would have been ICE-levels of racist about admitting people into protected zones. [I will note that in the mall episode, an asian character, Kim, strongly approves of a white character while denigrating a black one, so maybe that tracks.]
And then there’s building a non-racist future but somehow wanting to inject contemporary themes of race into it post-hoc. There’s that wildly weird episode of Star Trek: Next Generation where Cisco, the black captain, sees himself as explicitly black (“our people”), an identity that I think would be meaningless in the Star Trek universe. Ethnic identity is formed in opposition to majority culture, and otherwise isn’t that significant. [Not to mention the one black woman on the show shows up and magically becomes his girlfriend.]
So what are your thoughts? Is there a way to introduce and challenge concepts of racism in future fiction? Or would you rather not think about it at all and just give everyone some untroubled media representation?
For a good example of race-bending, see the first two seasons of the Interview with the Vampire TV show. I hear the third season is very, very bad though from all my friends who have watched it. I’ve only watched the first two seasons myself. They made Louis Black, not just visually but as part of the story. He existed as a Black man in the US throughout all the time periods the show is set in.
I don’t think it’s always wrong to write in an alternate universe where racism doesn’t exist, but 9 times out of 10 it works better as a writer to ask how racism interacts with the story you want to tell, rather than deciding it doesn’t exist in your universe.
I also do not believe fiction has any requirement to be morally didactic. You should portray racism in fiction because it exists in real life and you have things to say about it, not because you simply want to inform the audience that Racism Is Bad.
- The multi-ethnic village in the Mandalorian that has existed in harmony with nature for millenia, yet there are a wild variety of phenotypes in a small village of maybe 30 people.
I think for this one, the fact that the setting is “a long time ago in a galaxy far far away” means the humanoid aliens there have fuck knows what kinda trait inheritance biology, so portraying them with human actors of various ethnic backgrounds isn’t out of left field. I’ve also heard the fan theory that Star Wars humans aren’t actually even humanoid, their species is just portrayed that way for relatability (and the less humanoid other species represent less biological relatability to the “humanoid” main characters)
there’s also just the fact that some authors don’t wanna detract from the focus of their story by making everything 100% realistic and congruent with our reality. e.g. superhero stories aren’t about physics, they’re about various concepts like bravery, responsibility, etc. so even though it’s hilarious that Lois Lane should get trisected by inertia when Superman catches her, it’s not the narrative point
Ethnic identity is formed in opposition to majority culture
Say whaaaaat? That’s a wild take. Ethnic identity is formed by being part of a culture, not by being in opposition to another. Putting up Diwali decorations instead of Christmas ornaments doesn’t inherently mean you oppose Christmas. Just means you celebrate Diwali. Not everything is a competition.
Yes, that was poorly phrased. I think the intensity of your identification with ethnicity is definitely influenced by the majority view’s take on it. Think of all the white people who might have a passing familiarity with their heritage, but not really consider themselves to have much culture otherwise, compared to how strongly European Muslims cling to a Muslim identity in a hostile environment to American Muslims who (and I know the Islamophobia is still bad) can wear it a little more lightly.
Anyway, I think there’s a tension between celebrating ethnic identity and the melting pot, and I’m not sure how it would shake out in a Utopia. For instance, if people really did celebrate their ethnic identity but at the same time married and raised children easily outside of their ethnic identiy, what culture would the children of a Korean-German-Indian-Persian identify with? I think what it would turn into is people DIYing an ethnic identity for themselves based on their heritage, the same way people pick and choose which ancestors they identify with when they do geneology.
And to be fair to Star Trek, I think we see Star Fleet, which might be more heavily a racial mix than the Earth from which it draws its ranks, so I think part of my problem with the show is I assume Earth is mixing as much as Star Fleet is, which is probably not the case.
I feel like a lot of the pressures involving racial mixing in Star Trek kind of stop when there are other planets to settle. The internal migrations on Earth tend to go away when moving off world is a better key to success.
You also get the expanding idea of kin now that there are several other sentient species. Brock Peters plays Admiral Cartwright in Star Trek VI while saying a lot of racist shit against Klingons. I expect all the human racists got together to be racist against other species.
Yes, I notice that often in Trek non-Earth planets are pretty much a monoculture. The most diversity we’ll see is two classes or two factions to drive a conflict.
Which makes me think the eventual obliteration of that multicultural Terran diversity is implied.
I don’t think it’s a question of “should”, but “can”. The genre gives authors freedom to engage with the subject matter or not - at least more than standard literary or historical fiction does. As readers, we can enjoy fiction for its social commentary and also for providing an escape from reality.
There are a great many speculative fiction authors who have used genre as a tool to talk about racism and other larger social issues to great effect - think Octavia Butler, Tananarive Due, Stephen Graham Jones, Samuel R. Delany, Victor LaValle, Gabriel Garcia Marquez, Sheri S. Tepper, RF Kuang, etc. Speculative fiction is rich with opportunities for historical analogy, but it can also provide a lens through which we can explore a post-race future, or at least one where our conception of race has changed radically. I personally enjoy when authors tackle these topics explicitly.
That said, I value fiction for escapism, too. I’ve thoroughly enjoyed books and movies that are diverse for diversity’s sake, and don’t really discuss race at all - most recently the film Wicker, or Becky Chambers’s scifi novels. It doesn’t bother me when that diversity doesn’t necessarily make sense for the setting - if I’m already suspending my disbelief about a sentient basket man, I can suspend my disbelief about a few black or Asian people living in this medieval village.
Racism is unique to the past 500 years of history. Really. I am serious. In the ancient world, people categorized people based on the language they spoke and the wealth they had. Are you from a wealthy, educated nation? Can you speak our language? Can you offer something for trade? People weren’t dehumanized because they looked different; they were dehumanized because they behaved different. Categorizing people based on their complexion is a made up justification for the trans-Atlantic slave trade. In a world that never had the trans-Atlantic slave trade, nobody would discriminate on that basis.
Yes, I agree, racism is definitely an artifact of Europea colonialism.
My questions still remain, though.





