Basically, I think I am blissfully unaware of what actually works when trying to ask someone out in person. Like someone I’ve never talked to.
Obligatory mention that I am in my 30s now and have never really pursued people romantically before. I am pretty ignorant except for what I’ve heard from EITM radio show.
I recall seeing in quite a few movies (maybe older now) where people just decide to walk up to someone and ask for their number after saying some cheesy line. It’s not even a full pickup line, just something.
I’m sure the immediate answer here is “don’t believe everything from TV” and yes, while that is generally true, these movies and films must’ve gotten the idea from somewhere. I have to believe people did this at one point.
With everything being stifled to apps and online dating, one must wonder if it’s even socially acceptable to even try walking up to random person and asking for their number. (I don’t go to bars)
I also feel like even if it was “acceptable” to do, there’s probably some unmentioned consensus on why that works. Would love to hear what the unspoken rules are for this social interaction. Stories are also welcome.


I’m assuming you’re male–correct me if I’m wrong. I don’t think you can ask for someone’s phone number if you haven’t at least chatted for a while. If you have a conversation and hit it off, then you can exchange info. If it’s purely by sight and if you present yourself the right way (i.e. you’re a well dressed and attractive professional with good moves) then you can give the person your business card and hope that they contact you. That supposedly works for some people. It’s not my style at all so I can’t report from experience.
I never did dating apps but I answered a few Craigslist personals ads back when they had them. I’d usually send my own number or try to arrange a meetup. The most important tip I could give about answering ads in those days was to edit your emails carefully to have absolutely perfect SPAG (spelling, punctuation, and grammar) before sending. It used to help a lot. I don’t know if LLM’s have changed things since then.