One note: Hyphanet has a Usenet-like platform called Frost that does use key-based identities. So someone’s already done the work of hammering out the issues with key-based user identities on forums and probably if someone wanted to do that, it could be a useful guide.
As things stand today, the trust model used by the Threadiverse is “bootstrap trust of instances via TLS and X.509 certificates, and make a home instance trusted as to what users on that home instances does”. That has the benefit that one doesn’t have to do key distribution to clients and server admins generally understand setting up X.509 certs, since the Web uses them. But it alone isn’t enough to do end-to-end encryption or deal with malicious or compromised instances.
End-to-end encryption would also give us actually-private direct messages, which we don’t have today.
One note: Hyphanet has a Usenet-like platform called Frost that does use key-based identities. So someone’s already done the work of hammering out the issues with key-based user identities on forums and probably if someone wanted to do that, it could be a useful guide.
As things stand today, the trust model used by the Threadiverse is “bootstrap trust of instances via TLS and X.509 certificates, and make a home instance trusted as to what users on that home instances does”. That has the benefit that one doesn’t have to do key distribution to clients and server admins generally understand setting up X.509 certs, since the Web uses them. But it alone isn’t enough to do end-to-end encryption or deal with malicious or compromised instances.
End-to-end encryption would also give us actually-private direct messages, which we don’t have today.