Vicinus
- 34 Posts
- 182 Comments
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
2·2 days agoSeems like. Although then they will make alts on places like LW, though still it would be something rather than the current nothing in terms of separation from ML.
I suspect it would still be an improvement on the blanket acceptance they receive from the .ml admins.
https://web.archive.org/web/20240215044855/https://lemmy.world/post/11959030 - if you want the intricate details of Stamets creating TenForward. The story dates back to Reddit, goes through c/Risa@ST.W, and ends prior to him creating the second c/Risa@db0.
Appreciate the linked breakdown. I may have read that at some point, but at best, forgot most of it. Was looking for the faked evidence post and found: Stamets’ post after moving to DB0 from LW and an update a month later.
Though there are also an enormous slew of dead ones that people have to wade through as they search for what they like, which can cause confusion.
Yeah, I like that threelonmusketeers@sh.itjust.works is trying to get the different dispersed community mods and active posters to congregate (example).
… also supported by screenshots iirc …
Do you have a link to where that was demonstrated?
But if that exists, then I would totally change my position on this.
(April 27th) Here’s, surprisingly Stemets’, breakdown on the initial LW defederation of AN.
(April 29th) Yeah, the screenshots were shown to be doctored, with an active archive link to the supposed incriminating conversation that showed the conversation was doctored. My recollection is when asked for a response the .world admins just never responded or reiterated they were real and ignored the evidence.
That took forever to find. I thought it was in a deleted post were everyone was commenting on a Fediverse@LW post. Not sure what that one was about, but definitely part of all the arguments between LW + Rimu vs anarchist instances.
(May 4th) Looks like I forgot about the “Proof of AI-assisted political profiling by Unruffled @ lemmy.dbzer0.com” charge (by Rimu). Post has been deleted on Fediverse@PS. Here DB0 refutes Rimu (most of the way down that page of comments). I don’t want to re-read all about that drama, so take my recollection with salt and dive into the linked post if you’re curious. My recollection is one of the DB0 mods was trying out a llm user ‘evaluator’ and Rimu went with every DB0 mod and admin is using it. I am very much against the idea of an LLM moderator, but it wasn’t all of DB0 it was one person trying it out. Side note, I do recall them trying it out on Rimu. They deleted the comment and link later, but I followed the link before deletion. Don’t recall what it said though. I think maybe just that he was a neo-liberal and not a Zionist, but that is me reaching for a memory, so lots of salt on any specifics.
That’s still a great resource to learn what people say about us here though - see e.g. https://www.reddit.com/r/RedditAlternatives/comments/14gg9ue/this_is_my_problem_with_lemmykbinfediverse_i_dont/ a 3 year old post highlighting (with screenshots) one of the very MANY reasons that mainstream non-technical normies have enormous troubles navigating Lemmy.
Interesting read. I wonder if a automated “purge” of inactive communities (no posts in ~2 years) would help solve the “dozens of the same community problem”.
Checked out the community and there is a post from yesterday. Seems like fertile ground (“Federation, FOSS”, “To speak only with other human beings”, with good on-boarding: “More actual discussion and less hate mongering.”, “Old reddit from about 7 or 8 years ago, in terms of appearance, operation, and overall character …”).
… a ML mod told someone in a game community to outright kill themselves, then doubled and even tripled down indicating a desire to shoot the recipient himself.
Not surprising, and I suppose that’s your point.
… what I perceive about how such produces a “culture shock”, which turns mainstream normies away from this place.
It’s been a long time now since I visited Reddit, but I think the more shocking thing to a new user, wouldn’t be that someone made the comment, but that no-one removed it. The Fediverse/Threadiverse doesn’t have corporate owners trying to maximize their stock price. So, as long as users aren’t advocating for violence against other users (as in your ML mod point) or specific people IRL, I don’t really see a problem (ex. a random vent against the abstract rich and corrupt is fine by me).
I hear elderly neo-liberal people IRL advocate for extrajudicial killing of politicians, regularly. Of course they also are abhorred by violence against CEOs and the rich so, they seem to mostly be okay against anyone they don’t like (not a great moral barometer).
Threadiverse are truly serious about wanting this place to grow, then this extremism needs to be accounted for during the onboarding process. Ideally making it opt-in, as opposed to now where on Lemmy there is literally nothing that can be done about the situation, and on PieFed/PyLova (except PieFed.social now) it is opt-out instead.
Absolutely.
Not merely that but literally chiding me with such a look on their faces!!
I enjoyed that visual. Thank you :)
… why would a Ukrainian feel like they want to come to this place that is constantly saying that it was their fault that Russia had to put them down …
Yeah, what I see is the opposite, but I suspect that is my block list doing good work :)
(1) for many years a Google (not DuckDuckGo, actual Google) search of “Lemmy” would to to Lemmy.ml, rather than like LW or a more neutral third-party site.
Looks like it’s better now (Start-page 3rd result: join-lemmy.org, 6th result: lemmy.world, 48th result: join-lemmy again).
(2) The default on ML is to show “Local” rather than “All” content.
Not overly surprising to me. Authoritarians like to keep their narratives intact.
(3) There’s some other points of probably decreasing importance that nonetheless still play a role - like how communities suggested primarily favor the older ML instance rather than more active current ones …
Looks like they rank based on “Total Subscribers” rather than “Active”. That seems like a do-able fix, probably help communities stay alive too (new users going to the most active community).
People really seem to dislike all of that being thrown in their face. Read the comments on Reddit - when you do your onboarding analysis you’ll see. Make a poll maybe.
Not sure when that analysis is going to happen. I’m still kicking around how I would even get the data. I could apply to each instance (time consuming and potentially dox my location). I could message all the admins a message, but would they have the time or interest to respond. I think unverified users taking polls would skew the data. I don’t really know, yet, a good way to go forward. Let me know if you have any insights.
Religious/Centrist/etc.: aren’t the majority of Redditors Christians from the USA? And Muslims from the EU are also a strong secondary demographic.
I would have gone the other way on Reddit, with most being atheists (I believe it was one of the first communities and one of the biggest for like a decade). Never heard about “Muslims from the EU” being a thing. I stopped using Reddit years ago, so maybe that’s new.
I said centrist bc even if an American thinks that they are a flaming red commie, that still puts them more or less solidly in the realm of centrist compared to people here.
And ngl, many Americans are outright conservatives …
My understanding is American Centrist/Neo-liberal position is right-wing in Europe (possibly only “Western Europe”).
… just saying that IF these people (i.e. current Redditors) are the ones that we want to encourage to come here, THEN we will have to make this place more welcoming to them first.
I see your point. I think a blanket user-level “politics” block list would do the job well enough. I block almost all the meme communities, so not sure if those are “problematic”, but you listed them (“… in virtually all top-level communities too - Comics, Memes, News, etc.”), so probably them too.
It is very much doubtful that this place will ever go so far as to be welcoming to those people.
I don’t know. I think lemmy.world is probably a good fit for neo-liberal Reddit refugees.
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
2·4 days agoOh yes, the largest communities here are toxic shitholes. Politics, Memes, News, Comics, all are high contentious battlegrounds. Tbf the same is true and in fact far worse on Reddit, or was before the most heavy extremists were banned and now they are here instead of there anymore.
My block list is probably doing me many favors in regard to those.
Exception: PieFed.social bans all 3 of the tankie triad right away for new accounts, so that does significantly reduce that issue.
Yeah, I think getting more instances to institute an initial user-level instance block for the “triad” instances (like .zip) may be the best return on effort, at this point.
The history of TenForward was that the user Stamets had some drama with the !Risa@startrek.website mods and went off and started his own community …
I recalled the Star Trek communities splintered, but didn’t remember the specifics.
… So those two I would say are the most apt comparison - one is on Lemmy and the other on PieFed, but all other factors are the same.
I think we might have been discussing different points. It seems, to me, you may have been talking about Lemmy vs. Piefed and I was talking about Plurality/Flag-ship instances vs not.
There once was excitement that PieFed was going to overtake Lemmy. Now, even with v1.0 having been delayed for 18 months as you said, the excitement about PieFed is shrinking or already over.
Yeah, not many people holding Piefed’s ‘water’ at this point.
This here that exists now is pretty much what the Threadiverse will be for the next decade, as we continue to lose more people than we gain over time, and the software tools go into maintenance mode with a declining audience for their features offered.
I don’t know that we will still be like this in a decade, I still consider the Threadiverse to be at a ‘Beta’ version level (maybe ‘Alpha’). As bad as it may look at times, we aren’t losing users faster than we are gaining them, actually +3.8% compared to a year ago).
Agreed - this is what must be, the only issue is that new joiners need to adjust to it, like communities don’t exist for specific games so much as just a gigantic “games” community, and at best perhaps an exceedingly generalized genre (but not finer-grained subgenres).
I like that you brought the games community up, it seems like that is the only area right now big enough to host a variety of more niche active communities (ex. tabletop, patient gamers). So, might be the closest to breaking out into more singular communities (ex. !cyberpunk2077@lemmy.world, but possibly GTA6 will be the first majorly active one, assuming it’s not already and I’ve blocked it).
… then I added those details about who is going to cause it …
I’m going to still disagree that, if it were to happen, it would not be the flotilla causing it. In my view, the entity causing the response is the responsible party (like if Russia invaded a Baltic country and NATO declared war on Russia, Russia would have caused the war, not NATO).
… as even the upcoming tension that it might happen may already be affecting people’s recommendations as to what instances to join …
Possible I haven’t seen those discussions due to my blocks.
Here we are free. This is no walled garden, or rather it is many gardens, or I prefer the analogy instead of free trader and pirate ships.
I like your analogy. Never heard of the “free trader and pirate ships” version (flotilla == pirate ships, I’d guess).
… there are responsibilities that come with this freedom.
Well said.
None of which Reddit / X / Threads / Insta / Tiktok demands of them. So (most of them) will simply remain there.
Yep… :(
Of all the petulance… :-|
Yeah, my thoughts exactly. Plus breaking the Piefed -> Pylova conversion, seems to me Rimu is trying to wall his garden.
Related to your personal blocking (me too ofc, as with most Lemmings): you tend to miss out on such gems as https://lemmy.ml/post/55085010/28894101 (link is to a comment but the entire post is illustrative as well), and also this post https://lemmy.ml/post/54724340?sort=Top - make sure to sort comments by Hot or Top and see especially (but not exclusively) the top one. Calls for literal murder tend to turn mainstream normies away.
I was expecting much worse, based on what you were saying. I see where you’re coming from, but I don’t think posting or writing about a guillotine is that radical. I think most people don’t think the law works and isn’t likely to justice for the leaders/rich/whatever that are abusing/imprisoning/torturing/murdering/genociding people in broad daylight. So, not surprising to me they would call back to one of the well known times that those types of people got “justice”.
Another way you may want to consider is, what’s the difference between beating someone to death, starving them to death, poisoning to death (via tainted drinking water), withholding lifesaving medicine (ex. cancer treatment), or working someone to death. They all lead to death, usually just on different timelines and with different levels of direct interaction.
If a CEO jacks up the price of life saving medicine 1000% and now 10,000 people can no longer afford it and they die, did that CEO kill them? Some may say no, others may say yes. If the answer was yes, then if some random rich person is killing thousands a day/month/year/whatever, and the law will likely never touch them, what should someone do? If the only answer people give them is vote every other year, and hope that something that has never happened in their live happens, I don’t think many tempers will be quenched and people will search for and call for other solutions.
Every single person that I have mentioned the Lemmy platform to has outright chided me for telling them about it.
As in they checked it out and ran away screaming?
… not terribly welcoming to mainstream folk, who tend to be centrist, religious, and non-technical, unlike the prevailing trends here.
“religious” is an unexpected inclusion. I almost never run into anyone religious IRL or online. “centrist” is also a curious point, who’s “centrist” (American, European, Canadian, South Pacific, other; they are all different)? I think your environment may be affecting your viewpoint here.
Edit: New community you might want to check out: !blocklists@cozyver.se
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
2·5 days agoBlaze had calculated that at some point. It was quite awhile ago so that could have changed radically since then but… based on all of my personal experience things seem to mostly be moving in the opposite direction. e.g. as mander.xyz and slrpnk.net are both down (hopefully just temporarily), and smaller communities struggling mightily hence people remain in the biggest ones.
If there are multiple “active” communities of the same type on different instances, I tend to block .ml, .world, and .social communities (with the goal of helping de-centralization). So, I don’t have a good understanding of what an un-curated experience is like.
One example is !tenforward@lemmy.world retaining 5.77K MAUs compared to its offshoot !tenforward@piefed.world with just 0.08K MAUs.
I think a more equitable comparison would be with !risa@lemmy.dbzer0.com, that has “2K Monthly Users”.
We cannot support much niche content so it generalizes instead. The trends towards centralization are not being counter-balanced as much as previously by trends away from that.
In the short term, I don’t see this as particularly problematic, as long as the communities are dispersed across instances (helps congregate activity / seem more active).
Again, there was a huge shift to try to spread them around, but that was before the Flotilla began threatening to split the Threadiverse in two in consolidation with anarchist.nexus, and I for one tend not to post into communities located on dbzero anymore (I am not like morally opposed to such, but I just don’t try to prioritize it as I once used to).
… virtually a guarantee to happen if any single member of the Flotilla ever gets defederated from, I think this one not merely by LW but by any instance whatsoever, anywhere. That is no mere threat about some future vote that may or may not happen - that is outright policy, a settled matter, iirc.
I take the opposite view of that event. I see the flotilla as protecting against an authoritarian action by the .world admins, in the same vein/idea as “Then they came for the Jews, and I did not speak out—because I was not a Jew. Then they came for me—and there was no one left to speak for me.”. I have no faith the .world admins would have stopped at anarchist.nexus or would in the future.
That is probably due to your having blocked a lot of it?
Definitely possible. In a slightly related tangent, it looks like Piefed copied Pylova’s user block lists, but implemented them in an incompatible way. Also, possibly breaking instance conversion from Piefed to Pylova. Ugh…
That assumption might not be true. If the Flotilla defederates not merely from LW but from any instance that remains federated with it, then the schism would be wide indeed. But we’d have to read more the Flotilla policy to see (again) their stated aims. I forget the likelihood of this being true, but it’s definitely nonzero and more than just a vague conspiracy theory - whether it actually happens or not, people were most definitely clamoring for exactly that to occur, and it was not a fringe opinion iirc. Then again, after the cooling period, things probably will look different, so most likely the most extremist opinions will be drowned out by those wanting the greater convenience of remaining connected.
My recollection is that defederation would only happen to instances that de-federated from a member of the flotilla (like .world). De-federating from anyone that federates with .world would be massive self sabotage (in my view). Hopefully, that’s not what happens.
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
3·7 days agoAgreed about FiniteBanjo but iirc that definitely was not the only one …
So, I looked at the post without being logged in and I see your point. It seems I have blocked a fair share of contentious people. FiniteBanjo appears to be the only one that hasn’t warranted a block. My mistake for not checking an unfiltered version of the post. Appreciate the correction :)
Reddit offers the ability to lock a particular thread within a post (including I believe replies underneath it?), but I forget if that is possible in Lemmy or not.
That sounds like a pretty cool feature. I don’t link I’ve ever seen it implemented in the threadiverse though.
The tools tend to be significantly more primitive here, even if not enshittified for reasons of profit, just shit instead for reasons of not enough effort put in as compared to a multi-million dollar corporation hiring full teams of dedicated programmers. And then add the constraints of requiring working within the ActivityPub Protocol to enact federation and it becomes clear how much more difficult this task is to not merely replace Reddit but expand beyond it.
Yeah, we’re definitely on the slower road :/
… LW has >90% of the most active communities …
Do you have a source? Not trying to disagree, genuinely curious to look at the data. Activity Data puts Lemmy.world users originating/creating less than a 1/3 of total activity. So, it’d be interesting if everyone goes to lemmy.world communities. I know Mia’s Community Growth Posts often have Lemmy.world communities with the most new subscribers, but I don’t know if they have the most “active” communities by total number (posts, comments, visiting users).
New members will in virtually no way be guided into understanding any of this, leading to such posts as e.g. the recent one in Fediverse expressing absolute shock at having been banned from Lemmy.ml - as if that wasn’t a practically daily event here (or at least definitely would be if we had a sufficient populace to keep up that rate).
Yeah, better/any on-boarding is really needed.
We are fast falling into fragmentation, since we cannot maintain mutual respect. And especially if evidence really was being outright faked (I have no idea?), then all the more so.
I am not trying to suggest that such an action would signal the death knell for Lemmy, but the fact that it seemed imminent at one point and in fact is still high likely does not exactly signal health either, particularly in terms of a mindset of growth as opposed to mere existence.
I would actually go the other way and say things have calmed way down compared to like a year ago. I really thought the threadiverse was going to split during the false evidence against the anarchists and .world admin calls to de-federate. It seems, to me, that everyone has taken a step back and mostly just stays out of each other’s way now, which isn’t getting along, but doesn’t appear to be actively antagonistic.
I think, even if it did split, it wouldn’t be a unified split. All the “non-aligned” instances (not neo-liberal, not ml, not anarchist) is like 50% of the threadiverse and they would still see everything. So, I expect the “non-aligned” instances would increase in size and the “aligned” instances would decrease in size. Which is kind of what the data shows (all three “aligned” groups show decreases (anarchists the least) and “non-aligned” increasing on average).
I also am not opposed to decentralization, particularly since that’s already what we have now, but we should somewhere EXPLAIN this to new joiners. Although many years into this project, I haven’t really seen even the first steps towards such a thing.
Agreed about the swimming pool illustration regarding onboarding, except it’s far worse than that even: we here all learned GENTLY as the waters slowly rise about us, so we each picked up a few new concepts as the years trickled (or sped?) past us. New joiners are being asked to suddenly learn all of it at once, and even worse than that besides, to do so prior to making an account.
I don’t like questionaires, but something along the lines of the PieFed instance picker where the information is all laid out, filtering is possible based on it, and sentences explain the various choices possible would be a great way forward, if someone were willing to take up that project.
Yeah, unfortunately not enough developers/admin/mods/supporters to go around at this point. I already have a number of my own projects that don’t have enough time devoted to them, but I’m open to working on some on-boarding features/pitches with you, if you’re interested.
Another example is that I know of no possible way to view an instance’s set of rules from within Voyager. That entire sidebar might as well not exist for people using Voyager, which unfortunately also seems the most likely scenario for a new joiner coming here from Reddit?
I agree about Voyager’s inability to see the instance sidebar/set-of-rules. I made a post about it. We’ll see what happens.
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•What are you thoughts about (semi-) centralized moderation? (Updated with a more decentralized idea)English
2·10 days agoThe accounts are across many instances …
Good point. If they have a shared identifier (IP or something) than I could see the block list working. If not, and it’s probably not, then yeah, I don’t think the block list would be able to handle that spam.
I wonder if there is any approach that could. Different origins, different entrances, and different targets, that’s a difficult one. It’s not my knowledge base, so maybe something exists that could handle it? I’d be curious to hear about it, probably pretty cool.
Maybe machine learning on interaction rates (sign in to post timeline)? I’m assuming it’s automated though…
Vicinus@piefed.zipOPMto
Fedigrow@lemmy.zip•Weekly Thread – Identifying Community GapsEnglish
1·10 days agoI’m more confused now, but it’s fine if we disconnect.
To be clear, I don’t and didn’t intend my responses to be passive aggressive, if that’s how they come off.
Anyways, I wish you luck in your endeavor :)
Vicinus@piefed.zipOPMto
Fedigrow@lemmy.zip•Weekly Thread – Identifying Community GapsEnglish
1·10 days agoI’m confused now too. I think I understand your idea and goal. You and other users would pledge/signup to post to different communities at given intervals or based on last activity in the community. For the web-service, you’d want a place to sign up for communities, talk with each other, and get notifications/reminders (notifications within the web-service and via your threadiverse accounts).
“The Button” site/game can do all those actions. It’s not designed for it and it’s not its purpose, but the individual actions all exist and are utilized by and within the game. Utilizing its code, a new web-service could be built providing for all your requirements, without having to start from scratch.
You had mentioned integration within the threadiverse. The Pylova approach I mentioned would be that integration approach. It would have no relation with “The Button” game approach. You would need to convince Mia/the Pylova team to take on the task and build it out for you.
Feel free to let me know where the mis-connect is and I can take another shot at trying to help you.
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•What are you thoughts about (semi-) centralized moderation? (Updated with a more decentralized idea)English
2·11 days agoAppreciate the feedback :)
The difference between blocking and purging is that a blocked account is still residing on the instance (even more so for user blocks instead of admin blocks). As the data is still there, it opens possibility for legal trouble. Full purges by instance moderation action is different.
The scope of my proposal is not to help curate and filtering content for instances, but to enable widespread coordinated action against content which was already created and is harmful without any room for interpretation.
Makes sense. I suppose my described lists could also be made into purge lists.
That is a whole other issue. Scrapers and request spammers, not content spamming accounts, can be combated with already existing technology at the reverse proxy server. There are big crowdsourced IP banlists which are continuously updated.
Not my knowledge base, so good to know that already exists.
This would be the easiest solution. But I think it will lead away from individualism of instances, as all decisions are automatically applied, instead of only a manually reviewed subset.
Your idea with applying the mod action after a threshold of other instances did it too is something to consider. It will keep individualism but also creates “avalanches” once enough instances in the network agreed on a decision, which might be even better for propagating swift action against general harmful content.
Definitely a balance needs to be struck, between quick action and preventing abuse.
Vicinus@piefed.zipOPMto
Fedigrow@lemmy.zip•Weekly Thread – Identifying Community GapsEnglish
21·10 days agoAvoiding burnout is a high priority, and I’ve come close at times, so that’s a factor, too.
Yeah, I think that’s priority one, or should be, for community builders. Glad you’re taking care of yourself and not overdoing it :)
Sometime back I talked about a group ‘pledge-posting’ project that had its challenges in terms of coordinating people on such a venture, but today I realised that a web tool would probably be much preferable.
Better yet if such a mini-service could be integrated in to PieFed or Lemmy, so that one could get ‘the list’ and relevant notifications simply via their regular login. One stop shopping and all that.
I’m not sure if it’s open-source (didn’t quickly find source code searching), but “The Button” has interactions with users’ Fediverse accounts and can send notifications/messages after they sign up. So, it might be worth reaching out to Demigodrick@piefed.zip to see if you could view his code or if he’s interested in collaborating on your idea.
Via integration into the threadiverse, I’ve found Pylova the most responsive to feature requests and Piefed seem to following Pylova’s lead in several features (so perhaps backdoor into adoption by a larger portion of the threadiverse). So, might be worth reaching out to Mia (quokka@quokk.au) to see if she has any interest in working on that feature.
My guess is the easiest and fastest route would be if you could get Demigodrick to put up a service (stripped down features of “The Button”) for you/users.
Edit: for anyone interested in better understanding his idea, I found the last time we discussed the idea: https://piefed.zip/comment/7102549
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•What are you thoughts about (semi-) centralized moderation? (Updated with a more decentralized idea)English
10·11 days agoI think Pylova (a soft-fork of Piefed) is at the forefront of moderation tools in the threadiverse.
I think their recent addition of shareable user-subscribable block-lists is a good direction to go. I think this can be expanded to instance-level subscribable block-lists. There could be a variety of lists (CSAM, scrappers, scammers, agentics, etc.) and each instance chooses what list(s) to subscribe to or build their own for others to subscribe and contribute to. The lists would be easily fork-able so that any instance can take control of their own moderation, if they disagreed with an addition/subtraction to a list.
For some lists (like scrappers), I think automatic addition could be set up to quickly “inoculate” the rest of the threadiverse against them. Perhaps one approach could be any IP that clicks on a non-user clickable link or gets stuck(?) in Anubis could be added.
I think subscribable block-lists for instance admins could be a great way to protect the threadiverse (perhaps expanded to the fediverse as a whole or just any website in general) against any problematic actors quickly and at the first encounter (alternatively: after (x) # or % of instance admins add them to a list).
Apparently some of these lists may already exist in some form (@Christopher@lemmy.grey.fail: “I was able to implement community maintained blocklists.”). So, my thought would be to make sure these lists are a standard format (if they aren’t already) that instances can auto retrieve and contribute to.
Anyone: let me know if you have any thoughts or see any issues with the idea (constructive criticism only, please).
Vicinus@piefed.zipOPMto
Fedigrow@lemmy.zip•Weekly Thread – Identifying Community GapsEnglish
2·11 days agoHad to look up what a video game randomizer was. Seems interesting, though I think you’re right, and it’ll be pretty niche.
Regardless, thanks for the idea. I’ll put it in the list, with your instance suggestions :)
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
2·11 days agoA lot of the problems with Lemmy boil down ultimately to overall lack of moderation.
Yeah, I would say we are definitely at a “work-in-progress” level, with a ways to go.
The recent thread in the Fediverse community praising the devs of many Fediverse platforms is a great example: it became highly toxic, ultimately being locked.
I saw the post originally. Going back it looks like FiniteBanjo went to pick a fight. I’m not trying make any judgement on their comments, just that they appear, to me, to wanted to start an argument (“Well, not all of them. Some of them are a stain on this earth.”). Not surprised it was locked at that point.
… with the admins themselves literally flinging actual death threats against admins of other instances.
My recollection and understanding of that situation was that it was an inferred threat, that, when confronted, was immediately rescinded and that admin stepped down due to their actions. So, I think, it’s a bit disingenuous to use that as a negative against them. To me, they responded appropriately when confronted with how their message was taken (clarification that’s not how it was intended and then stepping down from their position of authority).
I believe soon after the .world admins faked “evidence” that the anarchist admins were really fascists trying to sow discord or something (I don’t recall the exact allegation, but I remember the evidence being shown and confirmed to be fake). My recollection is Rimu backed the .world admins even after their evidence had been shown to be faked. I want to say that is when Rimu introduced the instance “silencing” feature, to reduce anarchist influence after his and the .world admins’ attempts to expel the anarchists with the faked evidence failed.
So there will never be a solution to this step that involves all of us getting onto the same page.
Decentralization. There doesn’t need to be, in my eyes.
I do decry the right of places such as Chapotraphouse to exist, but I do think that they need to be labeled properly, with a warning label …
… the instance picker (the last time I checked) was very confusing and came nowhere close to explaining what individual users could expect when signing up to an instance.
… as people who jumped through all of the prior hurdles flee this toxic shithole …
On-boarding is a huge gap in my mind. From my view, we basically throw everyone in the deep-end and hope they learn to swim and aren’t too concerned with fixing the issue, because we all learned to swim, so why can’t they.
I could see an on-boarding that quickly explains the structure (like 2 sentences about decentralization/email-analogy and identifying a users name and instance. Then go into a quick questionnaire (for determining best host instance for them) about what kind of posts they want to see (one of those could be a quoted .ml account, to see if the new user wants to see “triad” content). From there some, basic filtering/block list yes/nos (block-list for spam accounts: yes/no, agentic accounts: yes/no, bot accounts: yes/no, etc.) and interested topics (software, cats, art, etc.). I think that would go a long way in helping get an easier and more welcoming environment (may only be fully possible via Pylova features at the moment (block-lists)).
Unfortunately, PieFed seems to be continually actively working against this goal now, making the options more opaque rather than transparent - e.g. any PieFed community on an instance that does not explicitly disable the downvote feature (and which ones have done that? how is anyone supposed to know!?) is shadow-censoring contributions offered from many different software platforms (Lemmy, Mbin, nodeBB, Friendica, Mastodon, etc.), without disclosure of that fact.
That’s a good point I hadn’t thought of before. I’m not sure how an instance could keep a user informed without keeping a larger database of community and instance settings. Alternatively, sending that info for each load or interaction the user makes. The larger database sounds much more reasonable, but still daunting and not easily implemented and probably with a significant compute cost.
… whose devs look to me to be tired on working to support new features, especially for PieFed.
This isn’t surprising to me. Piefed has 20% of the users Lemmy has (and that increase to 20% is relatively recent) and developer generally want to get paid for their work (especially if they don’t have a main corporate job).
PyLova might be the single best hope the entire Threadiverse has to grow. We’ll see what happens!
Yeah, definitely looks to be the brightest hope we have right now. Hopefully, they can keep up a sustainable pace and don’t burn out.
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
2·12 days agoI do need to find better language though, so that I don’t annoy people when I say that it is sometimes hard to have hope that this place will grow.
You may want to try using “feeling language”. I’ve found it helps a lot online and IRL.
Ex: “I feel like that …”, “My understanding of the situation is …”, “To me that …”, etc.
Bc really, growth isn’t the point?
Though it is necessary, even to remain afloat.
Agreed, for all the reasons you mentioned earlier, plus I think it would be nicer if the activity, administrative, and development load was spread out a bit wider (makes it easier on everyone/less burnout, and provides redundancies).
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
2·13 days agoThat said, the community that you pointed to might be in a weird lockdown state, since I noticed that it has zero active mods. See the sidebar on the home instance and then the modlog offers the further knowledge that the only prior mod has been banned from that instance. If you want to revive it, you could appeal to the instance owner and become the new kid of it?
I was going to take your suggestion, because I doubt it is much mod responsibility, but it looks like programming.dev was having federation issues when I tried to post and the post never made it. Remade it just now and it went through, no issues.
The people that have thrived here so far are those who approach it from an IT hobbiest standpoint and are willing to roll up their sleeves and get to work building it. But most people are not willing or capable to do likewise, which turns many away. The tools are still being built, and definitely lack polish atm.
Agreed. I feel it’s currently very much a make your own space and if people come by great, but don’t expect or rely on it happening.
But we are building them nonetheless (well, Mia is:-P, though we can help with suggestions!), steadily over time. So I am less concerned about current number of MAUs than in seeing the challenges be overcome, such as building these tools. Although that requires funding which in turn requires some level of MAUs, thus I am ecstatic about these subscribable blocklists to help keep people from fleeing this place!! 🤩
Agreed :)
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
2·14 days agoOh, do you mean the private voting issue?
If it helps, I had previously responded to some of the more controversial points that users had raised a year ago.
Honestly, you could probably lay out a dozen controversial decisions Rimu has made and I wouldn’t be able to pick which one I’m vaguely recalling.
I admit to being very wrong here - I thought, and even said publicly - that surely Rimu would reverse course and walk back that decision, as he had so very many others previously.
I thought so too.
He acts like Huffman, treating people as landed gentry on his platform. Which is… the truth!! Hence people have left it, and even more are choosing to simply go to it. Nonetheless, I truly do wish the best to the project… I just no longer have any hope that it will continue, most certainly not like it had in the past.
It’s his, but at the same time, being open source, it could very quickly not be (ex. Pylova). As long as there is a solid conversion path, Rimu could one day wake up and find .social is the only Piefed instance.
GET CREATIVE?!?
Rimu not only took away voting, and did so in a way that breaks the ActivityPub model - leaving users to scratch their heads wondering what error had occurred where the arrow turned green but the count did not change - but in response to why people were not allowed to vote anymore, he said to simply move on and do other things besides voting.
Yeah, his communication skills need significant work, which wouldn’t be so bad, if he was open-minded, but it really seems, as you’re saying, it has to be his way.
… the hidden, third option is simply to not engage with communities located on piefed instances anymore. And bam, just like that, communities such as !nonpolitical_comics@piefed.social had their contributions drop like a rock (I skewed those stats a bit b/c I seemed to forget for a moment and submitted 6 posts before I remembered, as I tried out different 3rd-party apps to see what those experiences were like).
Absolutely. This is what I love about open source and federation. It may take time, but the ‘system’ routes around ‘damage’. Looks to me like Pylova may be the route around the Piefed/Rimu damage.
REALLY! That’s amazing! I would guess a migration over from Reddit. I hope they feel welcomed.
I guess from Reddit too. It’s been pretty consistently 100+ new users a day. Given instance “stickiness”, I’d say ~60% stick around.
I’ve seen a couple posts from newbies, the threads look really positive, there still is the allow/block triad conversation/fighting, but it was very minor from what I saw.
About downvotes, I misrecalled: Mia said that it was added to the to-do list to be added for the next release, although that was 3 months ago, and yet I have not seen it added yet.
If you haven’t seen her response, it’s appears to be a user toggle-able setting, which may turn into an instance setting.
There are a lot of “unfriendly” aspects such as this to the Fediverse. I see some people fleeing now because their instance went belly-up - off-hand I can think of mander.xyz and slrpnk.net and… at least one more that I cannot now recall the name of (their admin team simply listed a single account beginning with “The “, which at least at one point had not posted for years), all of which are having issues. Of course that is simply par for the course for the Fediverse model!
Yeah, it’s unfortunate, but I think it could also be an opportunity to figure out problems/frictions and solutions. I think for the worry instances go down, a few things would inspire confidence, for me. Off-site backup redundancy (data), a set up non-profit with financial transparency (finances), and a “succession plan” (admins: if admin people want to leave they can but there is a plan in place to hand things off and replace them).
But less necessary are those bot spam posts made ostensibly to make the place look more welcoming and active and alive - at first glance, but then those accounts (almost?) never respond to anyone’s comment, which sours people and leaves a negative impression of this place as being a ghost town.
Agreed. I think clearly labeling that this a bot post, could be good to feature. I still like seeing articles, even if I don’t want to comment on them. Maybe having them separated out as RSS feeds would be better though. I think something is happening with regards to RSS and Piefed, but I didn’t look into the specifics.
But… it is simply not worth the effort, when Reddit and FaceBook and Insta and X and Bluesky have REAL (high amounts of) content, so investing all that effort to learn and block what they do not want will yield significantly greater dividends… they seem to think, and by the mantra that “the customer is always right”, they are correct.
One thing I kept hearing from the new users this week, is how calm it is here. Like there is much less antagonism, insults, and rage bait and much more thoughtful discussion and nice interactions. So, I think, the threadiverse will hold some of the new converts until they learn how to curate their experience better.
Thereby if we want to attrack them more, we need to offer such blocking by default, making unregistered bot accounts either outright illegal or at least opt-in rather than allowing them to be opt-out.
Now I would put my hopes into the shareable blocklists to do such.
Yeah, I think “informed default” (like .zip), where the blocks are setup by default, but new users are informed about them and there is an easy way to disable them, if the new user chooses to, is a good path forward.
About your idea: I disagree. An admin that is hosting their own instance is different than someone who is simply using an existing instance. Such a person should have access to a “connectivity health” monitoring tool yes, but I don’t see why it would need to be on a per-post basis.
I mean as opposed to having every single post do this across the entire Threadiverse, at all times.
Anyway, I feel like an admin tool would be a better fit for that situation than changing the way that all posts federated all of the time - if I understood you correctly there.
It seems I may not have conveyed the idea well. So to try again, my understanding is that an instance sends to the appropriate “hosting instance” a post or comment. My thought is, if it doesn’t already happen, have the “hosting instance” send an ‘acknowledgement’ back to the sending instance. Then, if the comment has been ‘acknowledged’, the sending instance would put an indicator on the comment (check mark or something) to show “yes, my user, your activity successfully arrived at it’s destination.”
In my mind, this wouldn’t be every instance checking every other instance’s user’s activity to make sure it federated properly. This would be an instance confirming things for only its own users.
For instance if I make a post to !Fediverse@lemmy.world, even as a mere user (not an instance admin) I can go over to that instance at https://lemmy.world/c/fediverse/ and look for my post there (similarly for comments). I have routinely done that many times in the past, especially from StarTrek.Website that had such horrible network connectivity at the time that I joined it, prompting me to seek out Discuss.Online that has such fantastic uptime due to spectacularly capable admins (including Jgrim the author of Sublinks).
Previously though, I would likewise post something and then getting zero up- (or down-) votes, go seek out why, and discover that my post had not federated. Worse, when it eventually did get federated, it did not appear to others as “new”, and instead looked like it had been submitted several days in the past, at which point people were not alerted to it, and it became buried amidst all the flood of prior posts that had already been engaged with, even though those had not been. It was quite sad, how bad the connectivity of the Threadiverse was 3-4 years ago:-(. These days it is a LOT better!
I’m think the feature I’m suggesting would do away with this “federation uncertainty friction”. I rarely go to check other instances to see if my comment or post has federated or not. I’m usually on mobile and this is not an easy maneuver, so I often have a question if my post/comment federated or if I’m only talking to myself. Not a great feeling and definitely reduces the urge to contribute, for me.
I just checked the post I made to the !servo@programming.dev community yesterday, did not federate (https://programming.dev/c/Servo is missing my post). Glad I spent time on that post… :(
I think the “acknowledgement” feature could also help elevate the issue entirely. I’m not sure how to ‘force’ a re-submission of my post, but if an instance didn’t get an ‘acknowledgement’ the instance could check that the '“hosting instance” is still receiving and then try resend the post/comment after a certain time interval.
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
2·14 days agoProbably would have missed it. Appreciate the tag :)
How votes are viewed is a user setting, letting anyone choose if they want combined, separate, or a percentage. Is this something you would also like settable as a global instance default choice?
Honestly, as long as I can easily enable it, it doesn’t matter to me if everyone has it by default (only viewed your instance without logging in). Might be worth a user poll, but I have no idea how wanted that feature is.
FYI I altered my [FR] on Codeburg to reflect you’d already implementing the feature.
We mostly use Grafna
Link doesn’t work, but I think I know what it’ll look like.
Given both your responses, it seems I didn’t conveyed the idea well to OpenStars. My understanding is that an instance sends to the appropriate “hosting instance” a post or comment. My thought is, if it doesn’t already happen, have the “hosting instance” send an ‘acknowledgement’ back to the sending instance. Then, if the comment has been ‘acknowledged’, the sending instance would put an indicator on the comment (check mark or something) to show “yes, my user, your activity successfully arrived at it’s destination.”
In my mind, this wouldn’t be every instance checking every other instance’s user’s activity to make sure it federated properly. This would be an instance confirming things for only its own users.
Hopefully that makes sense. I graphical up-time graph is probably nice to have too. I was going to say those are available on fediverse measurement sites, but with a quick look, it seems like that was a Fediverse-Observer (RIP) only feature.
Also I occasionally search for PyLova and I love reading this comment chain when I do, thanks for contributing so many ideas.
Happy to help and thanks for being so responsive, open-minded, and just all around great :)
Edit: when making my comment to OpenStars, I checked a post I made to the !servo@programming.dev community yesterday, which did not federate (https://programming.dev/c/Servo is missing my post).
I think the “acknowledgement” feature could also help elevate the issue entirely. I’m not sure how to ‘force’ a re-submission of my post, but if an instance didn’t get an ‘acknowledgement’ the instance could check that the ‘"hosting instance” is still receiving and then try resend the post/comment after a certain time interval.
Vicinus@piefed.zipto
Fediverse@lemmy.world•Fediverse Observer is offline and no longer being developedEnglish
3·12 days agoI am a bit behind in catching up - thanks for sharing all that, both the topics with the PyLova devs and making sure I was kept in the loop as well:-).
Yeah, no worries :)
I don’t recall the prior issue, unless it was the one with user blocking being silent. On that one I was swayed by the argument that it simply had to be that way due to limitations within Lemmy.
I don’t think that was it but maybe?
… all of which Lemmy will ignore, as is its right and choice to do so.
Agreed.
But the vote quota crosses a line where iirc it doesn’t even tell other PieFed instances - nor Mbin nor nodeBB nor Mastodon etc. - what is going on. It’s horribly designed, or at least it was upon release and if it has changed since then I have not heard of such. Some features take literally years to be implemented, but this one is slammed down everyone’s throats against all objections to the contrary without anyone seeming to have been heard?
Absolutely. I was ready to leave Piefed over it.
Sure, whatever, Rimu can do as he pleases, but it makes it really hard to hold out any hope for the future of this project when people keep losing investment in it (now Snoopy having become the latest casualty, seemingly? at least it appears that way).
Yeah, Snoopy leaving is interesting, in that I’m not sure how much new blood Rimu is going to attract in the future (he’s burned a lot of bridges). The Codeburg commits lists Rimu, Walter Schwenger (wsj018), and wltb as the only developers over the last 3 months. Looks like there were quite a few more other people pushing commits 4 months back. Looks like the Pylova split happened 5 months ago and a couple of the light commiters followed Mia to Pylova.
The Innuendo Studios YouTube series The Alt-Right Playbook does a superb job at explaining how someone can fall into authoritarian thinking.
Sounds interesting, I’ll have to check it out.
Particularly interesting are those in the outer circle of the onion-like layers that are shocked, Shocked I tell you, SHOCKED 😲 😳, when they find out that the people who had been screeching all along at the top of their lungs who they are, suddenly start doing the very things that they always said that they were going to do if they only had the power to make it happen.
It would be kind of funny, if the effects weren’t terrible :(
PieFed is still growing despite that though, just not by nearly so much or robustly …
Yeah, looks like there is some significant growth in the Threadiverse this week (~+750 MAU). Roughly 600 for Lemmy, 170 for Piefed, and -10 for Mbin.Edit: looks like I was running the analysis on the same processed data instead of processing each new day’s data before the analysis (only ran two of the scripts to check the daily numbers instead of all 3 :/). So, actually +250 MAU, rather than +750 MAU.I’ve brought up the topic of separating downvotes from upvotes with Rimu years ago, it seems very unlikely to happen. Mainly because he does not want it himself, therefore does not want to expend much effort to put it into the code (understandable), and also it is legitimately a difficult UI issue that he prefers to leave to others.
I vaguely recall this, so might have seen your post/comment at the time.
PyLova has already done it though …
They did? I just checked their instances and it has the same consolidated total votes UI. It would be great if they already did it, maybe it’s an option and not the default?
On a different note, I ran across a post who deleted there account, because almost no one was voting on their posts. I think it was a federation issue, as in the community hosting instance never received the posts and they only stayed local.
I was thinking maybe a check-mark or something to let a user know their post or comment was successfully received by the target/host instance. I don’t know if hosting instances tell sending instances they successfully retrieved data or not, so could be a significant increase in traffic.
Maybe not that significant though. Piefed only had ~1700 posts and comments over the last week, Lemmy top 20 most populated instances were ~12500 (“Activity” Data). Taking the most “active” instance (lemmy.world), they had ~4700 activities, assume worst case they are all for non-Lemmy.world communities. That would be 670 extra packets per day (28 per hour). That doesn’t seem too terrible. Thoughts?
Vicinus@piefed.zipOPMto
Fedigrow@lemmy.zip•Weekly Thread – Identifying Community GapsEnglish
2·18 days agoThanks for the suggestion. I’ve added it to the post body list :)
Vicinus@piefed.zipOPMto
Fedigrow@lemmy.zip•Weekly Thread – Identifying Community GapsEnglish
1·19 days agoNo worries :)
Also, if you didn’t see my edit, !andfinally@feddit.uk might also work for you.

No idea. I just know his summary matched my recollection of events.
I had one of those experience with Rimu, about data analysis. I laid out why he couldn’t make the claims he was making and he doubled-down and stuck his head in the sand. I try not to interact with his comments or posts now (no need to start drama where none exists).
No idea. I just linked his Star Trek updates, because I found them on while searching for the doctored evidence.
To be clear, Stamets is not the one making the claim the evidence is doctored (he just had a summary of interactions before that point in time), Loco_Mex@sh.itjust.works was posting the evidence.
I think that’s actually pretty common. In my experience, most people only take information from “trusted” sources. If you already distrust someone, it likely doesn’t matter what they say or how they say it.
Did not know that. Not overly surprising though.
No idea. Looking through all those past posts and comments, I recall seeing that the LW admins wouldn’t make decisions on removing power-abusive mods and tried to get others to do it. So, I wouldn’t hold out hope they ever did anything.
My recollection of that archival site was that it was using visiting users to DDOS-ing select websites. I don’t know of any falsifying of data/pages/pictures/etc.
Gotcha.
Fair points and it does seem like Piefed/Pylova have solved it with active users. I was using some Lemmy instances to search for the doctored evidence, so that was my frame of reference for the “search” functionality.
I know the feeling. I try to keep all my posts and comments neutral so nothing comes off biased, but I do try to add Pylova into any of my posts or comments about Threadiverse, so it has more exposure.
Haha. Not overly surprising, or counter to my understanding of the situation.
Thanks for the data source, some good stuff in there.
Interestingly, it looks like most of the data links eventually source to Statista, I can’t see their numbers without paying, but their graphs appear to visually show Reddit users decreasing in 2026, over 2025. It would be great to get the raw data to look at it in more detail, but oh well.
I think someone tried to make a christian instance. I blocked it quickly, but it may still exist.
Yep, I think this is back to ‘our on-boarding process is a failure and needs major improvements’ realm.
From what I’ve seen, most growth is in spikes (large increases and then significant decreases). So, relatively speaking, only dropping 30-40% from an all time max is actually really good (Mastodon is currently -73.0%). I think Loops is a really good example of what bad looks like (~29k -> ~4k, -86.3%). My generalization, from what I’ve seen, is 0 -> -25% is growing, -25 -> -80% is ‘stable’, and > -80% is ‘dying’. Not to say something ‘dying’ can’t come back to live, just that they are not in a good place and they haven’t been for a while.